T-Joints Stresses

This document describes a verification test where the results from Ashes are compared to the analytical solution for stresses in a tubular joint according to DNV RP-C203.
Note: T-joints are a special configuration of Y-joints, they are Y-joints where the brace is perpendicular to the chord. Therefore, and as specified in the standards, there is no mathematical distinction between T- and Y-joints, the same equations applies.

1 Test Description

We define a joint and apply a load in a given direction. The stress concentration factors (SCFs) are hardcoded. For each physical T joint, we define two joint sensors: one for the brace side and one for the chord side. This makes it possible to get different stresses on either side. For each joint sensor, we define 4 SCFs:
  • SCF_AS: Axial stress concentration factor at saddle
  • SCF_AC: Axial stress concentration factor at crown
  • SCF_MIP: In-plane bending stress concentration factor
  • SCF_MOP: Out-of-plane bending stress concentration factor
We then apply a load and compute the stress around 8 points based on DNV RP-C203.

Note: a positive stress means tension, and a negative stress means compression

2 Analytical Solution

Stresses at the 8 circumferential points of each sensor are computed following the description in the Fatigue document.

3 Test 1: T-Joint with Vertical Load

3.1 Model Configuration

The T-joint is defined with the following nodes:
Node X (m) Y (m) Z (m)
A 0 0 0
B 10 0 0
C 5 0 2
D 5 0 0
The cross section is circular hollow with:
  • Diameter:
    \(D = 0.6\)
    m
  • Thickness:
    \(t = 0.03\)
    m
Two joint sensors are defined:
  • Brace side: SCF_AS = 1.5, SCF_AC = 2, SCF_MIP = 2.5, SCF_MOP = 3
  • Chord side: SCF_AS = 1, SCF_AC = 3, SCF_MIP = 2, SCF_MOP = 5
A vertical load of
\(F = 100\,000\)
N is applied downwards on node C.

The model is shown in the figure below:


3.2 Cross-Sectional Area

The cross-sectional area of the circular hollow section is:
$$A = \frac{\pi}{4}\left(D^2 - (D - 2t)^2\right) = \frac{\pi}{4}\left(0.6^2 - (0.6 - 2 \times 0.03)^2\right)$$
$$A = \frac{\pi}{4}\left(0.36 - 0.2916\right) = \frac{\pi}{4} \times 0.0684 = 0.05376\,\mathrm{m^2}$$

3.3 Axial Stress

The load will produce a compressive stress in the member. The axial stress in the member is thus computed as:
$$\sigma_x = \frac{-F}{A} = \frac{-100\,000}{0.05376} = -1\,860\,119.05\,\mathrm{Pa} = -1.860\,\mathrm{MPa}$$
Since only a vertical load is applied with no moments, we have:
  • \(\sigma_x = -1.860\)
    MPa
  • \(\sigma_{my} = 0\)
    MPa
  • \(\sigma_{mz} = 0\)
    MPa

3.4 Expected Stresses at Eight Points

Point Brace Side (MPa) Chord Side (MPa)
\(\sigma_0\)
-3.720 -5.580
\(\sigma_{45}\)
-3.255 -3.720
\(\sigma_{90}\)
-2.790 -1.860
\(\sigma_{135}\)
-3.255 -3.720
\(\sigma_{180}\)
-3.720 -5.580
\(\sigma_{225}\)
-3.255 -3.720
\(\sigma_{270}\)
-2.790 -1.860
\(\sigma_{315}\)
-3.255 -3.720

4 Test 2: Y-Joint with Different Cross Sections

4.1 Model Configuration

The Y-joint is defined with the following nodes:
Node X (m) Y (m) Z (m)
A 0 0 0
B 8 0 0
C 4 0 3
D 4 0 0
The brace (member DC) has a circular hollow cross section with:
  • Diameter:
    \(D = 0.5\)
    m
  • Thickness:
    \(t = 0.025\)
    m
The chord (members AD and DB) has a circular hollow cross section with:
  • Diameter:
    \(D = 1.2\)
    m
  • Thickness:
    \(t = 0.04\)
    m
Two joint sensors are defined with the same SCFs as Test 1:
  • Brace side: SCF_AS = 1.5, SCF_AC = 2, SCF_MIP = 2.5, SCF_MOP = 3
  • Chord side: SCF_AS = 1, SCF_AC = 3, SCF_MIP = 2, SCF_MOP = 5
A vertical load of
\(F = 150\,000\)
N is applied downwards on node C.

The model is shown in the figure below:


4.2 Cross-Sectional Area

The cross-sectional area of the brace is:
$$A_{\text{brace}} = 0.03730\,\mathrm{m^2}$$

4.3 Axial Stress

The axial stress in the brace is:
$$\sigma_{x,\text{brace}} = -4.021\,\mathrm{MPa}$$
Since only a vertical load is applied with no moments, we have
\(\sigma_{my} = 0\)
and
\(\sigma_{mz} = 0\)
.

4.4 Expected Stresses at Eight Points

Point Brace Side (MPa) Chord Side (MPa)
\(\sigma_0\)
-8.042 -12.063
\(\sigma_{45}\)
-7.037 -8.042
\(\sigma_{90}\)
-6.032 -4.021
\(\sigma_{135}\)
-7.037 -8.042
\(\sigma_{180}\)
-8.042 -12.063
\(\sigma_{225}\)
-7.037 -8.042
\(\sigma_{270}\)
-6.032 -4.021
\(\sigma_{315}\)
-7.037 -8.042

5 Test 3: T-Joint with Horizontal Load

5.1 Model Configuration

The T-joint is defined with the following nodes:
Node X (m) Y (m) Z (m)
A 0 0 0
B 10 0 0
C 5 2 0
D 5 0 0
The brace (member DC) has a circular hollow cross section with:
  • Diameter:
    \(D = 0.6\)
    m
  • Thickness:
    \(t = 0.03\)
    m
The chord (members AD and DB) has a circular hollow cross section with:
  • Diameter:
    \(D = 1.0\)
    m
  • Thickness:
    \(t = 0.05\)
    m
Two joint sensors are defined:
  • Brace side: SCF_AS = 1, SCF_AC = 1, SCF_MIP = 1, SCF_MOP = 4
  • Chord side: SCF_AS = 1.5, SCF_AC = 1.5, SCF_MIP = 1.5, SCF_MOP = 6
A horizontal load of
\(F = 50\,000\)
N is applied in the positive x-direction on node C.

The model is shown in the figure below:


5.2 Second Moment of Area

The second moment of area of the brace circular hollow section is:
$$I = \frac{\pi}{64}\left(D^4 - (D - 2t)^4\right) = \frac{\pi}{64}\left(0.6^4 - (0.6 - 2 \times 0.03)^4\right) = 2.188\cdot 10^{-3}\,\mathrm{m^4}$$

5.3 Bending Stress

The horizontal load creates an in-plane bending moment at the joint. The moment arm is the length of the brace member DC, which is 2 m. The bending moment is:
$$M_y = F \times L = 50\,000 \times 2 = 100\,000\,\mathrm{Nm}$$
The bending stress at the outer fiber is:
$$\sigma_{my} = \frac{M_y \times r}{I} = \frac{100\,000 \times 0.3}{0.002188} = 13.711\,\mathrm{MPa}$$
Since only a horizontal load is applied creating an in-plane moment, we have:
  • \(\sigma_x = 0\)
    MPa
  • \(\sigma_{my} = 13.711\)
    MPa
  • \(\sigma_{mz} = 0\)
    MPa

5.4 Expected Stresses at Eight Points

Point Brace Side (MPa) Chord Side (MPa)
\(\sigma_0\)
13.711 20.567
\(\sigma_{45}\)
9.695 14.543
\(\sigma_{90}\)
0.000 0.000
\(\sigma_{135}\)
-9.695 -14.543
\(\sigma_{180}\)
-13.711 -20.567
\(\sigma_{225}\)
-9.695 -14.543
\(\sigma_{270}\)
0.000 0.000
\(\sigma_{315}\)
9.695 14.543

6 Test 4: T-Joint with Out-of-Plane Load

6.1 Model Configuration

The T-joint is defined with the following nodes:
Node X (m) Y (m) Z (m)
A 0 0 0
B 10 0 0
C 5 2 0
D 5 0 0
The brace (member DC) has a circular hollow cross section with:
  • Diameter:
    \(D = 0.6\)
    m
  • Thickness:
    \(t = 0.03\)
    m
The chord (members AD and DB) has a circular hollow cross section with:
  • Diameter:
    \(D = 1.0\)
    m
  • Thickness:
    \(t = 0.05\)
    m
Two joint sensors are defined:
  • Brace side: SCF_AS = 1, SCF_AC = 1, SCF_MIP = 3.5, SCF_MOP = 1
  • Chord side: SCF_AS = 1.5, SCF_AC = 1.5, SCF_MIP = 5, SCF_MOP = 1.5
A vertical load of
\(F = 40\,000\)
N is applied upwards (positive y-direction) on node C.

The model is shown in the figure below:


6.2 Second Moment of Area

The second moment of area of the brace is:
$$I = 0.002188\,\mathrm{m^4}$$

6.3 Bending Stress

The vertical upward load creates an out-of-plane bending moment at the joint. The moment arm is 2 m, and the bending moment is:
$$M_z = 80\,000\,\mathrm{Nm}$$
The bending stress at the outer fiber is:
$$\sigma_{mz} = 10.97\,\mathrm{MPa}$$
Since only an out-of-plane load is applied, we have:
  • \(\sigma_x = 0\)
    MPa
  • \(\sigma_{my} = 0\)
    MPa
  • \(\sigma_{mz} = 10.97 \)
    MPa

6.4 Expected Stresses at Eight Points

Point Brace Side (MPa) Chord Side (MPa)
\(\sigma_0\)
0.000 0.000
\(\sigma_{45}\)
-7.756 -11.63
\(\sigma_{90}\)
-10.97 -16.45
\(\sigma_{135}\)
-7.756 -11.63
\(\sigma_{180}\)
0.000 0.000
\(\sigma_{225}\)
7.756 11.63
\(\sigma_{270}\)
10.97 16.45
\(\sigma_{315}\)
7.756 11.63

7 Test 5: T-Joint with Combined Loading

7.1 Model Configuration

The T-joint is defined with the following nodes:
Node X (m) Y (m) Z (m)
A 0 0 0
B 10 0 0
C 5 0 2
D 5 0 0
The brace (member DC) has a circular hollow cross section with:
  • Diameter:
    \(D = 0.6\)
    m
  • Thickness:
    \(t = 0.03\)
    m
The chord (members AD and DB) has a circular hollow cross section with:
  • Diameter:
    \(D = 1.0\)
    m
  • Thickness:
    \(t = 0.05\)
    m
Two joint sensors are defined:
  • Brace side: SCF_AS = 2, SCF_AC = 4, SCF_MIP = 3, SCF_MOP = 5
  • Chord side: SCF_AS = 3, SCF_AC = 6, SCF_MIP = 4, SCF_MOP = 6
A combined load is applied on node C with:
  • \(F_x = 20\,000\)
    N
  • \(F_y = 30\,000\)
    N
  • \(F_z = -80\,000\)
    N

The model is shown in the figure below:


7.2 Cross-Sectional Area and Second Moment of Area

The cross-sectional area of the brace is:
$$A = 0.05372\,\mathrm{m^2}$$
The second moment of area of the brace is:
$$I = 0.002188\,\mathrm{m^4}$$

7.3 Axial and Bending Stresses

The axial stress from the vertical load is:
$$\sigma_x = -1.489\,\mathrm{MPa}$$
The in-plane bending moment from the horizontal load
\(F_x\)
creates a moment
\(M_y = 40\,000\)
N·m, resulting in:
$$\sigma_{my} = 5.484\,\mathrm{MPa}$$
The out-of-plane bending moment from the horizontal load
\(F_y\)
creates a moment
\(M_z = 60\,000\)
N·m, resulting in:
$$\sigma_{mz} = 8.227\,\mathrm{MPa}$$
The combined stresses are:
  • \(\sigma_x = -1.489\)
    MPa
  • \(\sigma_{my} = 5.484\)
    MPa
  • \(\sigma_{mz} = 8.227\)
    MPa

7.4 Expected Stresses at Eight Points

Point Brace Side (MPa) Chord Side (MPa)
\(\sigma_0\)
-19.43 -26.41
\(\sigma_{45}\)
12.99 12.69
\(\sigma_{90}\)
35.18 40.43
\(\sigma_{135}\)
36.25 43.72
\(\sigma_{180}\)
13.48 17.47
\(\sigma_{225}\)
-21.92 -26.09
\(\sigma_{270}\)
-47.09 -56.30
\(\sigma_{315}\)
-45.19 -57.12

8 Report

A time simulation of 5 seconds is run for each load case and the last 20% are compared to the analytical solution. If the results from Ashes are within 0.5% of the analytical solution, the test is considered passed.
The report of this test can be found on the following link:
https://www.simis.io/downloads/open/benchmarks/current/Tjoints_stresses.pdf